WebSite X5Help Center

 
Giulio V.
Giulio V.
User

Cls Problems Still not Addressed by Incomedia  en

Author: Giulio V.
Visited 1104, Followers 1, Shared 0  

I have been getting terrible information from Google about all my pages having CLS more tha .025

I had brought this to the developers attention in previous posts and have not received an appropiate response as to what we can do about this.

I was also told months ago that the developers were aware of this and will be addressing it in a new update.

The problem still exists for myself and many other users of the software.

So what is it going to be? Will you support your loyal customers or choose to ignore the problem?

Posted on the
9 ANSWERS - 1 USEFUL
Aleksej H.
Aleksej H.
Moderator

Hello. I sent a notification about your question to the company employees, expect an answer from them here in the comments.

Read more
Posted on the from Aleksej H.
Claudio D.
Claudio D.
Moderator
Best User of the month IT

@Giulio, non so a che post fai riferimento , comunque ...

... il valore del CLS non dipende certo da Incomedia...

Quello dipende da come hai strutturato tu il sito !

Se hai messo degli oggetti che al caricamento cambiano la dimensione/struttura/impaginazione della pagina , magari caricandosi anche lentamente, avrai un CLS pessimo.

Anche l'altezza dello sfondo del footer influisce. Se puoi inizia col mettere a 0 l'altezza dello sfondo del footer.

La struttura/impaginazione dipende solo da te.

Questi due miei siti fatti con Website , con i punteggi calcolati da Lighthouse, come potrai vedere non ho problemi di CLS o altro...

un altro:

Incomedia con i suoi developer potrebbero intervenire per altri fattori... ma per il CLS dipende solo da te.

Ecco ad esempio dove potrebbe intervenire Incomedia:

Read more
Posted on the from Claudio D.
Giulio V.
Giulio V.
User
Author

I have not heard a word from Incomedia regarding the CLS issues.

Claudio kindly did answer, but he wrote in Italian so I had to do a Google translate. 

As Claudio mentioned there are some items that Incomedia can address on thier side.

Will Incomedia address this issue or leave us in the dark?

Thank you, Giulio

Read more
Posted on the from Giulio V.
Giulio V.
Giulio V.
User
Author

No response from Incomedia Yet. At least please let us faithful users know something.

Read more
Posted on the from Giulio V.
Incomedia
Stefano G.
Incomedia

Hello Giulio

What Claudio reported surely is true. These tips given by Google on how to structure your website have to do with the design of the website mostly, although we can certainly take care of other aspects as well, which we are improving with every new release

Keep in mind that most of the aspects mentioned above have close to no impact to your website. Additionally, you could see that almost every website, even the big names, have such reports since the directives by Google are always pretty vague and don't really impact your ranking as much as they would have you believe, since many big website with similar issues rank top anyway.

Talking about css and js files for example, in order to optimize as much as possible these files, the dedicated minification was introduced in one of the most recent versions of the software. However, since many files are included by design, it is surely possible that Google's test might warn you about this

That being said, I dare to say that the amount of files generated is absolutely within acceptable parameters due to their extremely limited size and will not prove penalizing in their use.

That being said, the code is further improved at every update, so we'll keep the situation under check to see if we can improve all that can be improved in the future

Thank you for your feedback!

Stefano

Read more
Posted on the from Stefano G.
Giulio V.
Giulio V.
User
Author

Stephano,

Thank you for your quick replay and re-assuring that Incomedia is aware and working towards a solution to this matter.

Thank you again for assuring the code is in continual updates for this and other CSS and JS files.

Thank you so much, Giulio

Read more
Posted on the from Giulio V.
Giulio V.
Giulio V.
User
Author

CLS Problem Still Exists

As I am trying to clear up my CLS Issue on every page, please see the Attached lighthouse report photo which shows 2 Text boxes is causing 100% of the CLS on the page. 

I have seen this same issue on Lighthouse reports on many other pages on my website.

Why would a Simple Text Cell be the cause of my terrible CLS on most of my pages? What is the problem here?

Is there something I am doing wrong, or is it an inherrent defect in the X5 Pro code.

Why should something so simple as a Text Cell cause this problem?

I have been spending days on this issue with no positive solution.

Thank you to all that reply, Giulio

Read more
Posted on the from Giulio V.
Incomedia
Stefano G.
Incomedia

Hello Giulio

I don't really believe that those Text Cells are the issue. Keep in mind that automatic tools such as these can only go so far as to identify an issue correctly, and since the Text Cells are among those elements which are loaded immediately, it is hardly possible that they are the cause.

CLS can be caused by elements that are loaded after the rest of the page is loaded, thus causing the page to change height. This includes Lazy-Loading effects, Objects that load their content later such as some type of galleries and similar

Please investigate if your page makes use of any of this and consider whether it is worth it to just remove them. Usually, it isn't. Effect such as lazy-loading that can easily trigger CLS issues aren't real issues and these type of reports add nothing to the actual ranking of the website which is based on much more pressing factors

Verify what I mentioned on your page and keep me posted here

Stefano

Read more
Posted on the from Stefano G.